Turning Feedback into Amazon Growth: Expert Advice

Success on Amazon comes from understanding customer behavior, aligning listings with real expectations, and building trust through transparent messaging. This interview with BBE's Senior Growth Strategist, Benson Taylor, explores how expert Amazon marketers use customer reviews, purchase intent, and audience insights to improve product positioning, optimize listings, and strengthen conversion. Readers will gain practical insight into how high-performing brands turn customer feedback into scalable, data-driven growth strategies across the Amazon marketplace.

As a Brand Growth Strategist, how do you balance guiding brand partners through their Amazon growth journey while maintaining transparency and trust with customers?

When we’re talking about both the brand as our customer and the people actually buying the product, it really comes down to balancing those two with honesty and transparency. The brand has their vision of what they want to say, and the customer has what they actually need. Customers just want to understand what the product is, what it does, and whether it is right for them.

If they’re already on the listing, most of the time they do not need to be ‘sold,’ especially if they are loyal to the brand; they just need clear, truthful information. Our job is to prioritize what matters most by aligning the brand’s message with customer needs, using review insights to understand expectations and uncover opportunities for improvement.

When brands look to customer reviews for listing optimization and ad campaign inspiration, what is the most common insight sellers tend to overlook or misinterpret?

One thing sellers may end up hyperfixating on is the one- to five-star rating, and in each category, there’s an average. In the clothing category, for example, a 4.1 or 4.2 is actually a really good rating for that product category. But when you look at something else, like office supplies, a 4.7 or 4.8 is an ideal rating.

When you focus too much on the star rating of the reviews, you have to understand how those reviews are category-dependent. What you need to actually focus on is what the customer is actually saying about your product. For example, in clothing, if they are expecting thicker fabric and they get thinner fabric, there’s something that you have to change in your listing to make sure that they are getting the product that they are actually expecting, and then the reviews will follow properly. The fixation has to be on the customer dialogue about your product so that those ratings can go up.

What different types of customer “voices” should brands pay attention to when analyzing review data, and how can each uncover unique opportunities for growth and positioning?

There are generally two or three different types of customers that you have. One is the brand loyalists, or Advocates. They’re the most useful for refining messaging when you are looking for untapped benefits to your product. And then you also have the Skeptics, who are looking for an answer to their problem and can become converted to your brand if you solve that problem for them. They can be the most useful with direct studies of what led to conversion. Then you have the Critics. These can be brand loyalists, unconvinced skeptics, or completely unaware new-to-brand customers—they could be almost anybody. What they reveal are gaps in operations, product offerings, or customer expectations, and their hypercritical feedback often drives the most immediate opportunities for optimization.

When launching a new product on Amazon, how can brands strategically position their listings to encourage meaningful, high-quality customer feedback from the very beginning?

When you're launching a product, you want to get meaningful, content-rich reviews. Create listings with clear, informative content that highlights features and benefits without overpromising. Then focus on targeting high-intent shoppers who are already searching for products like yours instead of casting a broad, unfocused net. These customers leave honest reviews that reveal whether expectations were met or missed. You can then use that feedback to broaden your listing and reach shoppers with similar needs.

What is the most effective way to support a brand that consistently earns positive reviews compared to one trying to recover from ongoing negative customer feedback?

To help those listings and sellers that continue to receive ongoing positive feedback and reviews, we need to evaluate those reviews and continue to amplify by leveraging feedback in creative assets, scaling campaigns, and reinforcing what already works. Sellers get those reviews by honing in on the message and building, or continuing to build, trust with the client or with the customer. To help sellers that are consistently getting negative reviews, the focus becomes diagnosis and fixing the issues with the product, listing, or expectation gaps before scaling traffic.

How can partnering with a strategic agency help brands better understand and ultimately speak the language of their customers within the Amazon marketplace?

We help by taking out the guesswork. If you’re working with an Amazon marketing agency like BBE, we have the vast knowledge of our previous customers, multiple categories, and large data sets where we can move your brand from making reactive adjustments to building intentional listings that reflect how customers think and speak. The result is more precise targeting, stronger conversion, and a clearer, more consistent brand identity.

‍